BLOG POST8 min read

8 Renovation before and after You Should Know

Discover the top 8 renovation before and after strategies and tips. Complete guide with actionable insights.

real estatepropertyguidetipsblogmarketing
Published on August 20, 2025

Getting Started

In real estate, nothing tells a story of potential quite like a dramatic renovation before and after. Seeing a neglected space transformed into a stunning, move-in-ready home provides powerful proof of what’s possible. It’s not just about aesthetics; it’s about demonstrating value, inspiring buyers, and closing deals faster. This article moves beyond simple-before-and-after photos to provide a strategic breakdown of what makes a renovation successful and how to market that success effectively.

We will analyze eight iconic transformations from renowned design experts. For each project, we will dissect the specific choices made, from structural changes to finishing touches. More importantly, we'll explore how these real-world examples can be elevated using AI-powered tools like Pedra for virtual staging and rendering, giving you a clear playbook to apply to your own listings. For those embarking on their own transformation journey, gaining insights into effective project planning can be invaluable; mastering home renovation project management is a crucial first step.

This guide is designed for real estate professionals who want to turn renovation potential into tangible results. You will get actionable takeaways and replicable strategies to help you identify opportunities, communicate a property's hidden value, and ultimately, sell for a higher price.

1. Chip and Joanna Gaines' Fixer Upper Barndominium

The "barndominium" conversion is a prime example of a visionary renovation before and after, transforming an agricultural structure into a breathtaking residential home. This project, famously executed by Chip and Joanna Gaines, took a dilapidated 1,700-square-foot horse barn and reimagined it as a modern farmhouse. The core strategy involved preserving the barn's original soul-its soaring ceilings and rustic frame-while infusing it with contemporary comfort and the signature Magnolia style.

Chip and Joanna Gaines' Fixer Upper Barndominium

Strategic Analysis: Selling a Lifestyle, Not Just a Structure

The success of this transformation lies in its ability to sell a unique lifestyle. By keeping the dramatic cathedral ceilings and exposed beams, the project retained the authentic character that buyers find compelling. However, the true genius was integrating modern necessities seamlessly. An open-concept living area, a high-end kitchen, and large windows were added to make the space functional, bright, and perfect for family life. This balance turned a potential liability-an old barn-into an aspirational home.

Actionable Takeaways for Real Estate Pros

For real estate professionals, this project offers a powerful blueprint for marketing properties with unconventional potential. The key is helping clients see past the "before" to a stunning "after."

  • Highlight Structural Integrity: Before anything else, emphasize the building's solid bones. A structurally sound frame is the foundation for a successful and cost-effective renovation.
  • Use AI to Visualize Potential: For a raw space like a barn, clients struggle to imagine a finished home. Use Pedra’s AI staging and rendering to create photorealistic images of a fully furnished interior. Show them the "after" with an open floor plan, modern finishes, and cozy decor to make the dream tangible.
  • Focus on Character Preservation: Advise clients to maintain original elements like exposed wood or unique structural features. These details become high-impact selling points that differentiate the property in the market.

2. Drew and Jonathan Scott's Property Brothers Tudor Revival

The Tudor Revival renovation is a classic example of a thoughtful modernization that respects historical character. This project, a specialty of Drew and Jonathan Scott on Property Brothers, involved transforming a dark and compartmentalized 1920s home into a bright, open-concept space fit for a modern family. The core strategy focused on selectively removing walls to improve flow and light while meticulously preserving the home's original Tudor charm, like exterior half-timbering and interior archways.

For a quick reference on this type of project, the summary box below outlines the typical budget, timeline, and primary benefit.

Infographic showing key data about Drew and Jonathan Scott's Property Brothers Tudor Revival

As the data shows, achieving an open-concept layout is the main driver, turning a dated floor plan into a highly desirable feature.

Strategic Analysis: Blending Old-World Charm with Modern Function

The success of this renovation before and after lies in its strategic balance. Instead of gutting the entire structure, the project honored its architectural roots. The true genius was in creating an open-concept living area by removing non-load-bearing walls, which instantly made the home feel larger and more welcoming. This structural change was paired with essential system upgrades and the creation of seamless indoor-outdoor living spaces, making the property functional for today's buyer while retaining its timeless appeal.

Actionable Takeaways for Real Estate Pros

For real estate agents marketing historic properties, this project provides a clear roadmap for showcasing a home’s hidden potential. The goal is to help buyers envision a modern lifestyle within a classic shell.

  • Consult a Structural Engineer: Before suggesting wall removals, always advise clients to consult a structural engineer. This ensures any proposed changes are safe and feasible, addressing load-bearing requirements early.
  • Visualize the Open Concept with AI: Buyers often can't see past dark, cramped rooms. Use Pedra’s AI rendering to create a stunning "after" image that showcases an open floor plan. Virtually remove walls and stage the new, larger space to highlight improved traffic flow and natural light.
  • Emphasize Architectural Preservation: Advise clients to protect and restore original details like exposed beams, leaded glass windows, or unique trim. These features add immense value and become unique selling points that modern construction cannot replicate.

3. Tarek El Moussa's Flip or Flop Mid-Century Modern

Tarek El Moussa and Christina Haack's work on Flip or Flop frequently showcased the power of a great renovation before and after, but their mid-century modern transformations stand out. One notable project involved taking a neglected 1960s ranch in Orange County and turning it into a sophisticated, highly desirable home. The core strategy revolved around honoring the home's original architectural roots while executing a full-scale, modern update. This meant removing dated features like popcorn ceilings and installing floor-to-ceiling windows to create the seamless indoor-outdoor connection that defines this style.

Tarek El Moussa's Flip or Flop Mid-Century Modern

Strategic Analysis: Honoring Architecture to Maximize Value

The success of this flip hinged on respecting the home's inherent design language. Instead of forcing a generic modern farmhouse look, the renovation leaned into the mid-century aesthetic, which appeals to a specific and often affluent buyer demographic. The focus on clean lines, natural materials, and open sight lines created a space that felt both timeless and brand new. By investing in high-impact features like large glass doors and period-appropriate finishes, the project didn't just update a house; it resurrected a sought-after architectural gem, significantly boosting its market value and appeal.

Actionable Takeaways for Real Estate Pros

For agents dealing with properties from a distinct architectural era, this project is a masterclass in adding value by staying true to form. The goal is to modernize for today's buyer without erasing the home's soul.

  • Research the Roots: Before suggesting renovations, encourage clients to research the home's original architectural style. Understanding its key characteristics helps guide design choices that will resonate with buyers.
  • Visualize the Modern Potential: Many buyers can't see past dated finishes. Use Pedra’s AI rendering to show them how the home could look with modern, style-appropriate updates. Create visuals that replace old carpeting with sleek flooring and show walls opened up to enhance natural light.
  • Invest in Windows and Doors: Emphasize that in styles like mid-century modern, windows and doors are not just functional; they are core design elements. Upgrading them can dramatically improve curb appeal and the interior living experience, offering a high return on investment. For more insights into this strategy, you can explore the principles of successful house flipping in our detailed guide on the Pedra blog.

4. Leanne Ford's Restored by the Fords Victorian Townhouse

The revitalization of this 1890s Pittsburgh Victorian townhouse is a masterclass in blending historic preservation with modern design. Leanne and Steve Ford tackled a property suffering from decades of neglect, transforming it into a luxurious, functional home. Their approach centered on celebrating the home's original architecture while introducing Leanne’s signature monochromatic, white-on-white aesthetic. This renovation before and after showcases how to honor a building's past without sacrificing contemporary style.

Strategic Analysis: Modernizing History Without Erasing It

The success of this project hinged on a delicate balance. Instead of gutting the interior, the Fords meticulously restored original features like intricate plasterwork and exposed brick, making them focal points. The strategic use of white paint throughout created a cohesive, gallery-like feel that unified disparate spaces and amplified natural light. This modern canvas allowed the home's historic soul to shine through, creating a property that feels both timeless and current. The project proves that historic homes can appeal to modern buyers when the renovation is thoughtful and intentional.

Actionable Takeaways for Real Estate Pros

For agents dealing with historic or older properties, this project provides a clear strategy for unlocking immense value. The goal is to frame the home's age as an asset, not a flaw.

  • Document and Highlight Original Details: Before listing, catalog all unique architectural elements like millwork, fireplaces, or original flooring. These are irreplaceable features that create an emotional connection with buyers.
  • Use AI to Bridge the Imagination Gap: Buyers may see an old, dark interior and feel overwhelmed. Use Pedra’s AI tools to show how a simple, cohesive color palette can modernize the space while preserving its character. Show them a virtually renovated space with updated, yet period-appropriate, finishes. Explore our guide to learn more about how to renovate houses virtually.
  • Advise on Strategic Modernization: Counsel sellers to focus on updates that matter: a modern kitchen, updated bathrooms, and efficient systems. By integrating these necessities, you make the historic charm practical for today’s lifestyle, maximizing its market appeal.

5. Ben and Erin Napier's Home Town Cottage Revival

Ben and Erin Napier's transformation of a neglected 1940s cottage in Laurel, Mississippi, is a masterclass in a heartfelt renovation before and after. This Home Town project focused on reviving the home's soul, not just updating its surfaces. The Napiers' approach involved preserving the building's inherent charm while infusing it with personalized, handcrafted elements and modern functionality, turning a forgotten house into an idyllic family home.

Strategic Analysis: Selling Authenticity and Story

The success of this revival stems from its focus on authenticity and storytelling. Rather than a gut renovation that erases the past, the Napiers’ strategy was to celebrate it. By restoring original hardwood floors, preserving unique architectural details, and adding custom millwork, they created a narrative. The home wasn't just remodeled; it was honored. This strategy appeals to buyers seeking a home with history and character, a powerful differentiator in a market saturated with generic flips.

Actionable Takeaways for Real Estate Pros

This project provides a valuable lesson in marketing properties with historical charm. The goal is to help buyers connect emotionally with the home's unique story.

  • Emphasize Original Features: Point out and protect original elements like vintage hardware, moldings, or built-in shelving. These are not flaws to be removed but assets that add immense value and character.
  • Showcase "Lived-In" Potential with AI: For a dated cottage, it can be hard for buyers to see beyond old wallpaper or a cramped layout. Use Pedra’s AI to virtually stage the space with warm, inviting furniture and modern decor that complements the home’s vintage aesthetic. This helps buyers envision a comfortable, contemporary lifestyle within a historic shell.
  • Tell the Home's Story: Research the home's history and incorporate it into your marketing. Frame the renovation as the next chapter in the property's life, inviting new owners to become part of its legacy.

6. Jasmine Roth's Help! I Wrecked My House Ranch Renovation

Jasmine Roth's work on Help! I Wrecked My House showcases a critical type of renovation before and after: the rescue project. This California ranch transformation is a powerful example, turning a DIY project gone wrong into a functional and beautiful family home. The original homeowners had created structural hazards and design dead-ends, leaving the property in a state of disrepair. Roth's strategy was to first stabilize and correct the mistakes before executing a cohesive, family-friendly design that unlocked the home's true value.

Strategic Analysis: Selling a Solution, Not Just a Vision

The success here is rooted in problem-solving. While other renovations sell a dream, this one sells a solution to a nightmare. Roth’s team addressed compromised walls, faulty wiring, and poor layouts, transforming major liabilities into assets. The focus on creating bright, open spaces with smart storage and durable materials made the home not just aesthetically pleasing but highly livable. This approach rebuilds buyer trust by demonstrating that even a "wrecked" house can be made safe, sound, and stylish.

Actionable Takeaways for Real Estate Pros

For agents dealing with properties plagued by failed DIY efforts, this project provides a clear roadmap for recovery and marketing. The key is to frame the renovation as a professional course correction.

  • Prioritize a Professional Assessment: Before listing, hire a licensed contractor to document all structural and safety issues. This report becomes a tool to reassure buyers that all problems have been identified and will be professionally addressed.
  • Visualize the Fix with AI: A buyer's imagination will get stuck on the visible damage. Use Pedra’s AI renovation tools to show them the "after." Create renderings that not only depict a beautiful new kitchen or living room but also highlight corrected layouts and enhanced functionality, turning a negative into a positive.
  • Budget for the Unknown: Advise sellers to build a significant contingency fund (20-25%) into their renovation budget. DIY disasters often hide more problems, and being financially prepared prevents the rescue project from becoming another stalled endeavor.

7. Good Bones Victorian Mansion Restoration

This ambitious project by Mina Starsiak Hawk and Karen E. Laine is a masterclass in a historic renovation before and after, breathing new life into a deteriorating 1920s Victorian mansion in Indianapolis. The "Two Chicks and a Hammer" team undertook the massive challenge of transforming the dilapidated property into a breathtaking single-family home. The renovation went far beyond cosmetics, requiring extensive structural reinforcement, complete replacement of outdated systems, and meticulous restoration of original architectural details like ornate woodwork and stained glass.

Strategic Analysis: Balancing Preservation with Modern Livability

The triumph of this restoration lies in its delicate balance between honoring historical character and delivering modern functionality. Instead of gutting the interior, the team painstakingly salvaged and restored original elements, preserving the home's irreplaceable soul. The strategy involved weaving modern conveniences-like an updated kitchen and luxurious bathrooms-into the historic fabric without compromising its integrity. This approach created a one-of-a-kind property that appeals to buyers who crave both classic charm and contemporary comfort.

Actionable Takeaways for Real Estate Pros

For agents dealing with historic or architecturally significant properties, this project provides a clear roadmap for maximizing value. The goal is to showcase how preservation can be a powerful selling point.

  • Prioritize a Historic Assessment: Before listing, advise clients to consult with historic preservation experts. Identifying which elements are original and restorable helps in planning a renovation that enhances, rather than erases, value.
  • Virtually Restore and Stage: Many buyers can't see past peeling paint and damaged trim. Use Pedra’s AI to create renderings that not only repair the damage but also stage the home with period-appropriate yet modern furnishings. This helps buyers visualize the property's glorious potential.
  • Market the Story: A historic home’s story is a unique asset. Emphasize the history and the craftsmanship of the original details in your marketing. Highlight the careful restoration process as a key feature that distinguishes it from new builds.

8. Christina on the Coast Modern Farmhouse Kitchen

Christina Haack’s modern farmhouse kitchen renovation is a quintessential example of how to transform a home's most important space. This project took a cramped, dated kitchen and reimagined it as a bright, open-concept hub perfect for family gatherings and entertaining. The core strategy involved removing walls, maximizing natural light, and implementing a design that blends classic farmhouse elements with a clean, contemporary California aesthetic.

Christina on the Coast Modern Farmhouse Kitchen

Strategic Analysis: Selling an Aspirational Lifestyle

The genius of this renovation before and after lies in its focus on lifestyle integration. By creating a seamless flow from the kitchen to living and outdoor areas, the design sells the dream of effortless California living. The large central island becomes more than a prep space; it’s a social center. The combination of bright white cabinetry, warm wood accents, and high-end finishes creates an atmosphere that feels both luxurious and welcoming, a powerful combination for potential homebuyers. This approach makes the kitchen the undisputed heart of the home.

Actionable Takeaways for Real Estate Pros

This kitchen makeover provides a proven formula for increasing a property's value and appeal. The key is to show buyers how a strategic kitchen update can redefine the entire home.

  • Focus on the Floor Plan: Emphasize to clients how removing a non-structural wall can dramatically improve flow and perceived space. An open-concept kitchen is one of the most requested features by modern buyers.
  • Show the Potential with AI: A dated kitchen can be a major turn-off. Use Pedra’s AI kitchen renovation tool to instantly show clients how the space could look with new cabinets, countertops, and an open layout. Presenting a stunning "after" visual helps them emotionally connect to the property’s potential.
  • Advise on High-ROI Finishes: Guide sellers to invest in quality countertops and timeless fixtures. These details signal quality and have a significant impact on a buyer’s perception, making the investment worthwhile. For more ideas on updates, you can learn more about how to modernize your home.

Before and After Renovation Comparison of 8 Projects

Project 🔄 Implementation Complexity ⚡ Resource Requirements 📊 Expected Outcomes 💡 Ideal Use Cases ⭐ Key Advantages
Chip and Joanna Gaines' Fixer Upper Barndominium Moderate - structural & insulation challenges Moderate - use existing structure, reclaimed materials Increased property value, spacious feel Renovating barns into family homes Cost-effective, unique character
Drew and Jonathan Scott's Property Brothers Tudor Revival High - wall removal, permits, historic restrictions High - structural engineer, permits, smart tech Bright, open-concept, modernized historic home Historic homes needing open layouts Improved flow, energy efficiency
Tarek El Moussa's Flip or Flop Mid-Century Modern High - specialized contractors, structural mods High - quality windows, materials High resale value, timeless appeal Mid-century homes in desirable markets Strong buyer interest, distinctive style
Leanne Ford's Restored by the Fords Victorian Townhouse Very high - extensive restoration & compliance Very high - expert contractors, longer labor Luxurious modernized historic home Historic townhouses needing full restoration Preserved character, sustainable
Ben and Erin Napier's Home Town Cottage Revival Moderate - labor-intensive custom work Moderate - skilled craftspeople, local materials Affordable, functional family home Small cottages emphasizing craftsmanship Affordable, community connected
Jasmine Roth's Help! I Wrecked My House Ranch Renovation Moderate - correcting DIY errors Moderate - structural repairs, smart fixes Maximized space, functional family living Rescue projects fixing prior mistakes Budget-conscious, practical
Good Bones Victorian Mansion Restoration Very high - extensive structure and historic work Very high - specialist contractors, costly materials Preserved heritage, market uniqueness Large historic mansions requiring full restoration Significant value increase, sustainability
Christina on the Coast Modern Farmhouse Kitchen Moderate - plumbing, electrical updates Moderate to high - quality finishes, appliances Enhanced functionality, increased value Kitchen remodels for modern farmhouse style Improved workflow, buyer appeal

Final Thoughts

As we've explored these incredible renovation before and after transformations, a clear pattern emerges. Success isn't just about demolition and reconstruction; it's about strategic vision, a deep understanding of a property's potential, and the ability to communicate that potential to buyers. The work of icons like Chip and Joanna Gaines, the Scott Brothers, and Leanne Ford teaches us that every home has a story waiting to be told. The "before" is just the first chapter.

The most powerful takeaway is the strategic use of design to solve problems and create emotional connections. Whether it's removing a wall to craft an open-concept living space or restoring historic details to honor a home's heritage, these projects are masterful lessons in value creation. They prove that a well-executed renovation before and after project does more than just update a space; it redefines its entire market appeal.

Your Path to Transformation

Mastering the art of the renovation before and after is a game-changer for any real estate professional. It’s about looking past the current state of a property and seeing what it could be. This foresight is your most valuable asset.

To begin applying these lessons, start with a clear framework:

  • Analyze the "Before": Go beyond surface-level flaws. Identify the core issues holding a property back. Is it a dysfunctional layout, a lack of natural light, or an outdated style that alienates modern buyers?
  • Define the "After": Create a compelling vision. Who is the target buyer? What lifestyle are you selling? Use this to guide every decision, from the floor plan to the final fixtures.
  • Bridge the Gap: Develop a tactical plan. Prioritize changes that deliver the highest ROI and emotional impact. This is where you connect the practical steps of renovation to the strategic goal of a successful sale.

As you consider your own home's potential, remember that transformative projects aren't limited to the specific styles seen on TV. For example, explore tips for creating a luxurious finished basement, which can dramatically increase living space and home value. The principles of identifying potential and executing a clear vision apply to every corner of a property.

The ultimate lesson from these examples is that vision sells. Buyers often struggle to see past faded paint and awkward layouts. Your job is to show them the future. By presenting a clear, beautiful, and functional "after," you remove uncertainty and allow them to emotionally invest in the home. This strategic approach accelerates sales, increases offer prices, and builds your reputation as an agent who delivers exceptional results.

Ready to bring your own renovation visions to life? With Pedra, you can instantly visualize any property’s potential, creating stunning virtual stagings, decluttering, and AI-powered renovations in minutes. Stop telling buyers about the potential and start showing them with compelling before-and-after visuals that close deals faster.

Felix Ingla, Founder of Pedra
Felix Ingla
Founder of Pedra

Related Posts